It’s no crime for amateur players to have a drink

It’s no crime for amateur players to have a drink

Vincent Hogan

Published 07/06/2014|02:30

There was nothing but 100 per cent effort went into Tipperary’s clash with Limerick as Donal O’Grady and Brendan Maher battle for possession

On Tuesday in Youghalarra Church, Donie Nealon clasped Brendan Maher’s out-stretched palm with both hands, leaning in close for a private word.

The warmth was palpable between the past and present of Tipperary hurling. Maher had come to pay his respects at the funeral of Nealon’s beloved wife Kitty and you didn’t need to be a body linguist to know the direction their conversation was taking.

Donie, a pivotal figure in the most storied Tipp team of all was, you sensed, suspending his personal trauma to counsel the current centre-back against any loss of hope. Two days after defeat by Limerick in Thurles, Maher would have appreciated that.

Tipp championship losses tend to uncork many different shades of public recrimination and it can’t have been easy for the Borrisoleigh man to present himself into that great Newtown throng so soon after Sunday. Few people understood that better than Nealon.

The fall-out to defeat would sharpen later in the week when Noel Dundon penned an extremely forceful comment piece in the ‘Tipperary Star,’ questioning the coterie of Tipp players who took to two days of drinking “in and around Thurles” following the county’s fourth consecutive championship loss.

Dundon drew comparison between the so-called “Monday Club” drinkers of a beaten team and their victors convening, on the same day, for a recovery session at UL Limerick.

There is no doubting that his article faithfully reflected the rising anger of a broad rump of Tipp supporters who see certain elements of the current team as lacking the kind of competitive integrity and selflessness now considered de rigeur in other inter-county camps.

The expectation today is that a county man treats his body as deferentially as a Ming vase, both before and after competition. He is pursuing a challenge (hobby anyone?) where the average body-fat is that of a rope.


So, in and around whatever career he might be hoping to pursue, the county man must live his life as if booked into a health spa.

Tipp’s difficulty seems to be that they have those willing to follow that path (Brendan Maher undoubtedly among them) and others inclined to equivocate.

Stories about the social habits of certain players have been recurring ever since Liam Sheedy stepped down as manager after the 2010 All-Ireland win. The concern, since, hasn’t even been so much about the drinking they do as the seeming incompetence with which they do it.

The act of irritating people by drawing attention to yourself creates a climate in which wholly imaginary liaisons easily gain credence.

Then run that narrative parallel to Tipp’s recent habit of suffering some kind of vertigo in the home straight of big games and it isn’t difficult to trace the natives’ appetite for recrimination. Tipp, the story goes, should go to battle in cowboy hats, not helmets.

But you have to remind yourself of a number of factors here.

Firstly, Tipp lost the league final to Kilkenny only after extra-time. Secondly, Sunday’s two-point defeat to Limerick probably had more to do with defensive indiscipline than lack of stamina. Thirdly, they are amateurs.

In a week when pay-per-view in the GAA is making such headline news, that last one is worth repeating. It is a strange conceit of the modern inter-county life now that amateur sportsmen are meant to live cleaner, more temperate lives than curates on retreat.

Professional rugby and soccer teams routinely unwind with post-game beers, yet the broad preference is that amateur GAA players desist. The earliest Tipp will resume championship action is June 28, yet their supporters will be profoundly unamused by stories of that session.

Dundon’s article was, thus, perfectly legitimate because it represented a frustration now widely shared among Tipp hurling people. But it also served to pour an interesting light on the increasingly skewed philosophy of life in the GAA.

The Association insists that pay-for-play is not on the agenda, but, if so, how can we honestly reconcile the juxtaposition between Sky Sports’ cameras in Nowlan Park tonight and the outcry over amateur hurlers “drowning their sorrows” last weekend? How is one image compatible with the other?

The elephant in the room is that it isn’t.

Defeat pushes strange buttons in a GAA life and, for Tipp, the hope will be that this week’s acrimony creates an energy that might just carry them back into contention. But bear in mind that GAA players misbehaving are not in breach of any contract. Not yet at least.

What they break is an age-old duty of trust. And, much as we might not like it, that is no crime.

– See more at:

Comments are closed.